Fwd: Muses' return:

From: Wade T.Smith (wade_smith@harvard.edu)
Date: Thu May 24 2001 - 03:24:34 BST

  • Next message: Wade T.Smith: "Fwd: An addictive thrill"

    Received: by alpheratz.cpm.aca.mmu.ac.uk id DAA17978 (8.6.9/5.3[ref pg@gmsl.co.uk] for cpm.aca.mmu.ac.uk from fmb-majordomo@mmu.ac.uk); Thu, 24 May 2001 03:28:55 +0100
    Subject: Fwd: Muses' return:
    Date: Wed, 23 May 2001 22:24:34 -0400
    x-sender: wsmith1@camail2.harvard.edu
    x-mailer: Claris Emailer 2.0v3, Claritas Est Veritas
    From: "Wade T.Smith" <wade_smith@harvard.edu>
    To: "Memetics Discussion List" <memetics@mmu.ac.uk>
    Content-Type: text/plain; charset="iso-8859-1"
    Content-transfer-encoding: quoted-printable
    Message-ID: <20010524022435.AAA21238@camailp.harvard.edu@[]>
    Sender: fmb-majordomo@mmu.ac.uk
    Precedence: bulk
    Reply-To: memetics@mmu.ac.uk

    Muses' return:
    Scholar gives a voice to ancient music silent for millennia

    By Ken Gewertz
    Gazette Staff


    Imagine a time in the remote future when all that is known of our world
    is what archaeologists have been able to excavate from the rubble - a
    handful of tantalizing puzzles with most of the pieces missing.

    Suppose the scholars of that time were able to decipher the librettos of
    Verdi, Puccini, and Oscar Hammerstein, the lyrics of Cole Porter, Irving
    Berlin, and Joni Mitchell, but could not reproduce one note of their

    If we could communicate with those future historians, surely we would
    want to tell them: You are missing the best part of what we loved about
    these productions, the part that thrilled us, lifted our hearts, the part
    we tapped our feet and snapped our fingers to.

    That is more or less the situation we face when we read the poetry and
    drama of ancient Greece. The epic verse of Homer, the love poems of
    Sappho, the tragedies of Sophocles, and the comedies of Aristophanes -
    all were accompanied by music. And yet that music - its melody, harmony,
    and rhythm, its very sound - has been almost completely lost to us.

    Almost, but not quite. A number of clues remain, and one scholar believes
    that he can fit them together and resurrect a music that actually can be
    played and sung. His name is Dimitrios Yatromanolakis and he is
    conducting his research as a member of the Harvard Society of Fellows.

    "Almost any ancient Greek text we read today contains a reference to
    music. How can we understand this culture unless we understand its
    music?" Yatromanolakis asks.

    Despite the cultural importance of ancient Greek music, classical
    scholars of the 19th and 20th centuries have pronounced it dead,
    unrecoverable. Yatromanolakis believes this pronouncement is premature.

    "There is a large corpus of theoretical writings on ancient music, and we
    have actual musical scores that have rarely been studied or talked about.
    It seemed to me that since we have all this material, the obituary can't
    be true."

    The reason the puzzle of ancient Greek music has remained unsolved for so
    long, Yatromanolakis believes, is that the necessary interdisciplinary
    approach has not yet been brought to bear on it. Up until now, the few
    scholars who have studied ancient Greek music have either been
    musicologists who lacked classical training and could not adequately
    interpret the ancient texts, or else classical scholars whose
    understanding of music left something to be desired.

    "The ball keeps being tossed back and forth between these two groups, and
    in the end no breakthroughs are made and we continue to say that ancient
    Greek music has died."

    Yatromanolakis may be ideally qualified to make a breakthrough in this
    field because he combines both types of expertise. Brought up in
    Herakleion on the Greek island of Crete, he earned a bachelor's degree in
    classics from the University of Athens, then went on to earn a master's
    and D.Phil. from Oxford University.

    At the same time, he was developing his knowledge of music, concentrating
    not only on history and theory, but on performance as well. The
    instruments he has mastered include piano, guitar, sitar, tabla, and
    kithara, and he is equally at home with Mozart as he is with the music of
    Ali Akbar Khan, Caetano Veloso, or Ladysmith Black Mambazo.

    The kithara, a Greek stringed instrument that goes back to the time of
    Homer, plays an especially important role in Yatromanolakis' efforts to
    find the key to the music of the ancient Greeks, for it is on this
    instrument that much of this music can be properly performed.

    Although he stipulates that performance is only a secondary concern (his
    first interest is filling in the blanks of our scholarly knowledge of
    ancient Greek music), he and several friends from Oxford get together
    periodically to play these ancient pieces and are planning to produce a
    CD of their work.

    Yatromanolakis believes that when the CD appears, it will be by far the
    most accurate rendition of ancient Greek music to date (there have been
    several attempts in the past, but he believes they rely too much on
    imagination and not nearly enough on knowledge). And while his own
    attempt may not be an exact replication, he does not consider this
    uncertainty a reason to abandon the project. After all, he points out,
    there is much controversy about how music of the 17th and 18th centuries
    was performed, but this does not deter modern musicians from playing it.

    Yatromanolakis is full of praise for the Harvard Society of Fellows for
    supporting him in his research and for Harvard classicists like Gregory
    Nagy and Gloria Pinney for offering their expertise.

    Their encouragement must seem sweet indeed since the quest, for the most
    part, has been a lonely one. Yatromanolakis estimates that there are only
    a few other people in the world seriously pursuing a similar line of
    research. They are far outnumbered by the skeptics and naysayers who
    proclaim the music's demise. But Yatromanolakis, with a confidence that
    borders on the evangelical, has no use for those who declare his goal

    "To say that ancient music has died is an old-fashioned view," he says.
    "This is not a healthy skepticism, in my opinion."

    According to Yatromanolakis, those who predict failure for the project
    may be unaware of the sources that are available, or of the progress that
    has been made in interpreting them.

    These include:

    the musical tables of Alypius, a Greek scholar thought to have lived in
    the fourth century A.D., which Yatromanolakis has used in new ways to
    decipher the Greeks' notational system;

    actual musical settings of poems by Euripides and later writers,
    preserved on papyri, parchment, and stone inscriptions. In these ancient
    scores, the notation for the singers was written above the words while
    that for the instrumentalists was written between them;

    ancient works on musical theory by Euclid, Pseudo-Aristotle, Aristides
    Quintilianus, Boethius, and others. One of these theoretical works is by
    Aristoxenus, a pupil of Aristotle. Last summer in the Bibliotheque
    Nationale in Paris, Yatromanolakis discovered an unpublished work that
    follows Aristoxenus' views on music and harmonics; he is now editing it
    for publication.

    Yatromanolakis has studied these and numerous other written texts,
    examined vase paintings for clues about the place of music in Greek
    society, and probed the remains of ancient instruments in the hope of
    constructing modern equivalents. He has also examined other ancient music
    systems that may throw light on the way Greek music was played and

    "I always try to cross-examine these sources to increase my chances of
    coming to valid and safe conclusions," he said.

    Yatromanolakis plans to bring together much of this material in a book he
    is writing with the working title of "Society in Contest: Poetic and
    Musical Competitions in the Archaic, Classical, and Hellenistic Eras."
    The title refers to the numerous contests held all over Greece in which
    poets, playwrights, singers, dancers, choral groups, and instrumentalists
    vied for the glory of being chosen number one. The book will provide a
    cultural context for his effort to reconstitute Greek music.

    He is also revising an earlier book-length study titled "Sappho in the
    Making," an examination of the seventh century B.C. woman poet whose love
    lyrics exist only in tantalizing fragments.

    With his visionary outlook, single-minded application, and devotion to
    the most rigorous scholarly standards, Yatromanolakis seems likely to
    achieve startling breakthroughs in his discipline.

    "After such a long tradition of studying the classics, we must broaden
    our focus to include all possible aspects of the classical world. When we
    achieve an understanding of ancient Greek music, I believe it may
    revolutionize our field."

    Copyright 2001 by the President and Fellows of Harvard College

    ===============================This was distributed via the memetics list associated with the
    Journal of Memetics - Evolutionary Models of Information Transmission
    For information about the journal and the list (e.g. unsubscribing)
    see: http://www.cpm.mmu.ac.uk/jom-emit

    This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Thu May 24 2001 - 03:32:39 BST