From: Keith Henson (email@example.com)
Date: Fri 29 Jul 2005 - 03:46:38 GMT
At 07:36 PM 28/07/05 -0700, Scott Chase wrote:
>Seriously, to understand the controversy over Potter I
>think an exploration of recent history holds the key.
>EP might provide *a* basis in primordial psychological
>motivations, but not *the* overarching answer.
EP is an abstraction level over biology and under (human) behavior just
like biology is an abstraction level over chemistry and below EP. If there
is such a thing as an overarching understanding of everything, it extends
from quarks right up to abstract paintings.
As far as using EP to account for the Potter controversy, perhaps it could
be done. I have invoked capture-bonding to understand army basic training,
hazing, SM, and battered wife syndrome. But I have no clear idea of what
drives cultural shifts. I can't account for the sudden (over 2-3 years)
shift where kids (in Northern California) just quit reading books by
Heinlein, Asimov and Clarke in the early 70s.
Nor can I account for the 20 year difference in the takeoff of life
insurance between the UK and the US or the 60 year delay for life insurance
to become accepted in France or the sudden (and damned lucky) drop in the
birth rate in Northern Ireland back some 35 years ago.
I have proposed that the more stressed a population is, that is the more
people see the future as bleak, the more it is subject to xenophobic meme
amplification. This makes sense as an evolved psychological trait and it
*does* account for the rise in suicide terrorists.
>need to get over themselves already. They tend to
>revert to the kneejerk adaptationist stance no matter
>how many times nonaptive byproducts are acknowledged
>then quickly forgotten.
It is certainly true that EP advocates say that human psychological traits
such as we have are the result of selection pressures in the stone
age. But if you were going after me, please note that I have written
extensively about such matters as vulnerability to drug addiction being a
nonadaptive byproduct of psychological traits that were essential for
reproduction when out ancestors lived in hunter gatherer bands..
PS *Are* there any EP advocates on this list besides me?
This was distributed via the memetics list associated with the
Journal of Memetics - Evolutionary Models of Information Transmission
For information about the journal and the list (e.g. unsubscribing)
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Fri 29 Jul 2005 - 04:05:18 GMT