From: Reed Konsler (firstname.lastname@example.org)
Date: Thu 22 May 2003 - 18:49:50 GMT
"The venue is not only the space in which the performance takes place, but the time in which it does."
OK, I'll agree, a performance requires a unit of space-time in which to
"and it is not only the time and the place, but the commanded aspects of
allowance for the performance. It is both history and continuance."
All of that is in the brains of the participants. The physical props do not
command or expect anything. Does a broom expect to sweep? Does it get
frustrated if it doesn't of confused if it is danced with instead?
"It is the very ground upon which the performer and the observer stand."
If you mean that in a concrete way, it's just a prop. If you mean that in
an abstract way, the information making up the "ground" is recorded in the
minds of the participants.
"It is not absent, or unnecessary, and every single memeinthemind model,
including yours, has attempted to dismiss it."
I'm not saying it is absent, or unnecessary, or dismissing it. I'm saying
the irreducible, necessary part of the venue is physically located in the
brain. I will agree that there must be some unit of space-time...some
media...for a performance to occur within. But, after the performance has
occurred, that media is neither necessary nor sufficient to "maintain" the
pre-performance. The mechanism that leads from one performance to another
requires, and only requires, a single human brain. Everything else is just
> Memes are small units and probably can't replicate any
> more than a particular gene can. A virus is a collection large and
> enough to cause the host to express a performance.
Did you really mean to say this? Is this not a radical departure, both in
methodology and definition?
I don't think so. I got the distinction from _Virus of the Mind_ : a very
elegant, succinct, and practical description of memetics, written by a very
intelligent, caring person. I recommend it to people whenever it seems
appropriate. Sometimes even when it doesn't. It seems I can't help myself.
Must be good memes.
This was distributed via the memetics list associated with the
Journal of Memetics - Evolutionary Models of Information Transmission
For information about the journal and the list (e.g. unsubscribing)
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Thu 22 May 2003 - 18:57:36 GMT