From: Reed Konsler (firstname.lastname@example.org)
Date: Thu 15 May 2003 - 20:36:51 GMT
Here is a question.
There is a piece of music that I play on the piano. I perform it many times
sequentially. I teach it to many people who also perform it sequentially.
When I teach it to one particular person, Double A, I make a mistake and add
an extra note. Double A performs that mutated piece of music.
1) Where is the meme between the time I make one performance and the
2) Can I predict with any confidence ahead of time that a future
performance will be identical to a past performance? If so, on what basis
do I make that claim? For instance, if I say "I've played this same song a
million times before" does that make any difference?
3) Can I predict with any confidence that Double A will play the same
piece I do BEFORE I hear his performance for the first time? Should I
expect that when I ask him to play the piece on the piano that he will even
use the keys to make sound? If so, on what basis do I make that claim?
4) For me to mimic you, do I need to have a model in my head of your
performance? How does your performance lead to my performance? What is the
5) Is it possible to perform a piece inside your own head, to yourself?
For instance, can you compose or review music or writing without making a
sound or motion?
6) What percentage of performances do you think are external as opposed
to internal (within your own mind)? Is that an invalid question?
7) If I get into a car accident and part of my brain is damaged such that
I can still play the piano, but I can no longer "remember" (for want of a
better word) the particular piece...what happened? Why would damage to my
brain break the string of sequential performances?
This was distributed via the memetics list associated with the
Journal of Memetics - Evolutionary Models of Information Transmission
For information about the journal and the list (e.g. unsubscribing)
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Thu 15 May 2003 - 20:44:47 GMT