From: Wade T. Smith (firstname.lastname@example.org)
Date: Fri 03 Jan 2003 - 14:44:54 GMT
‘Cultist’ Cloning Advocates Test Definitions of Faith
By Geraldine Sealey
— If Claude Vorilhon is right, Dec. 13, 1973, was a big day for
the planet Earth.
That's when 4-foot, dark-haired, olive-skinned extraterrestrials
appeared to Vorilhon at a volcano in France and told him they
created human life in their image using DNA, he says.
The scientifically advanced visitors, known as Elohim,
supposedly stayed in contact with humans through the years via
prophets such as Buddha, Moses, Jesus and Mohammed, says
Vorilhon, now 56 and a former car-racing journalist.
Now known as Rael, Vorilhon seeks to spread a message of science
and spirituality and build an embassy for the extraterrestrials
in Jerusalem. Last week, much of the world was introduced to the
Quebec-based Raelian movement when the group claimed to have
created the first human clone — a step toward achieving eternal
life, they believe.
Since then, Raelians have been widely ridiculed as cultists.
Indeed, many practices and beliefs of this sect stray far from
the mainstream: the UFO theme park, the emphasis on open
sexuality, and the leader himself, who wears his hair in a bun
perched on his balding head.
But just how much more far-fetched is Raelianism from other
faiths? Just the thought of comparing Raelian beliefs to
Christianity, Judaism or Islam surely raises sacrilegious flags
for many, despite the freedom of religion encoded in the
Many religious scholars, though, see a broader definition of
religion — and the Raelians fit it, they say, just as
Scientologists, Jehovah's Witnesses and Mormons do.
Instead of the word "cult," considered by religious scholars to
be the most derogatory term of their field, modern sects are
known as "new religious movements" in academic lingo. Just
because a belief system is young does not make it wrong,
After all, the Romans once considered Christians superstitious
for not worshipping the emperor, said Frank K. Flinn, religion
professor at Washington University in St. Louis. "Yesterday's
cult is tomorrow's religion," he said.
People Who Believe Weird Things
Flinn, who several times has appeared as an expert trial witness
to present a legal definition of religion, says he identifies
three essential characteristics of a religion. It must possess a
system of beliefs that explain the ultimate meaning of life,
must teach religious practices and norms for behavior and
conduct rites and ceremonies, and must unite a body of believers.
The Raelian movement fits this definition, he said. According to
their Web site, Raelians claim 55,000 worldwide followers,
although this number has not been independently verified.
Not everyone, of course, is so generous to the Raelians.
"This is from this one guy Rael's one hallucinogenic experience.
It's a cult of personality. He's a pretty dynamic, persuasive
fellow," said Michael Shermer, director of the Skeptics Society
and author of Why People Believe Weird Things . "I've never
seen any verification of his 55,000 members."
The Raelians are just the latest fringe religious group to make
headlines in recent years and raise questions about what
constitutes religion and what makes a cult.
Scientologists have caused a stir with celebrity believers such
as Tom Cruise and John Travolta, bitter legal battles and
accusations of abuse and corruption. The Hare Krishnas defended
themselves against brainwashing allegations and gained a
reputation for soliciting new members in airport terminals.
While many religious scholars are accepting of new sects,
apocalyptic groups often garner criticism. Heaven's Gate, whose
members committed mass suicide and made the sect extinct in
1997, believed a spaceship riding behind the comet Hale-Bopp
would take them to heaven, for example.
"With groups like Heaven's Gate you might be able to use that
term [cult]; they wreaked a great deal of harm," said J. Gordon
Melton, director of the Institute for the Study of American
Religions and author of Why Cults Succeed Where the Church
From UFO Sect to Mainstream Religion?
To many Americans, though, Heaven's Gate equals Hare Krishna
equals Moonies. New beliefs don't win widespread popularity here
and are even less welcome than a century ago, Melton said.
Early in the 20th century, 30 percent of Americans were
affiliated with a religion. Now, 80 percent claim to be members
of a particular church. "The chances of [a new sect's] success
are less because the pool of unaffiliated is less," Melton said.
A century ago, Americans considered Mormons cultists, in part
because of their polygamous ways. But now, many prominent
Americans belong to the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day
Saints and Mormons (who no longer advocate polygamy) are
Is such acceptance possible for Raelians?
Usually, successful new religious groups are evangelistic and
aggressive about recruiting members, and maintain a fairly low
level of tension with mainstream society, Melton said.
Success for the Raelians may mean dropping their affiliation
with UFO-style beliefs. "Mormons as polygamists couldn't do it.
Mormons not as polygamists could do it," Melton said.
While some observers say the recent publicity about Rael's
cloning claims may boost the sect's profile, some scholars say
the foray into science may prove calamitous for the movement.
Cloning Failure Could Test Faith
Clonaid, the Raelians' scientific arm, claims to have cloned the
first human, but so far the company has not provided scientific
proof. And even if it did create a clone, costly mistakes in the
process could test Raelians' faith and further ostracize the
"In terms of their own belief system, what they're doing
[cloning] is ethical, but not in terms of broader society," Flinn said. To illustrate his point of just what can go wrong, Flinn pointed to the first cloned mammal, Dolly the sheep, who has experienced premature aging and arthritis.
For others though, greater costs of Raelians' faith could come
to science itself, whether or not their cloning efforts were
"This could be an important development for medical technology
that's now tainted," Shermer said. "The real guys are worried
Congress will panic and pass restrictive laws [on cloning]
because some UFO nut says he did it."
This was distributed via the memetics list associated with the
Journal of Memetics - Evolutionary Models of Information Transmission
For information about the journal and the list (e.g. unsubscribing)
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Fri 03 Jan 2003 - 14:45:34 GMT