From: Lawrence DeBivort (firstname.lastname@example.org)
Date: Sun 15 Dec 2002 - 04:37:02 GMT
Yes, I'm surprised you pulled MEMRI's quotes about itself off of MEMRI's
page for us. But note who they quote: Krauthammer, Nordlinger, Peretz,
Lantos, Adelman, etc. These are ultra-pro-Zionists. There are some
interesting names there, like Woolsey, Lewis and Friedman. Lewis, who is
greatly respected in Middle East historical studies, is an early Zionist.
Friedman is in my opinion, also excellent, but as he is the first to admit,
pro-Israeli. Jim Woolsey is also excellent, but on other matters, but no
expert on the Middle East. Now, if he were commenting on arms control (in
which he did some very important and difficult work for the US and the
world), his praise would be more weighty. I haven't heard of David Tell.
Maybe HE is an expert on the Middle East and without a dog in the fight?
I went back to the MEMRI site, and was able to link up some of the materials
you quoted to the video material--many thanks; as I said in my last email,
though, this leaves us with the question of MEMRI's own biases.
I notice they don't reveal who is running the site, or funding it. (Somehow,
I don't think your dedication and $20 bucks to them is covering the budget.)
So, who is behind the site??? Who is the director of MEMRI? Who is on their
advisory board? Who on their Board? Who is staff director? Maybe I'm
missing the part of their site that provides this information. Joe, can you
point me to this information? You have piqued my curiosity.
Well, you came back to Pipes and the anonymous "ibn Warraq" -- your
admiration for Pipes speaks volumes, and makes it easier to reach
conclusions about how much credibility your admiration and financial payment
to MEMRI should be given.
I notice that you ignore my challenge to you to produce ANY complaints that
have been made of my provision of references. If indeed you can't find any,
a simple apology on your part will suffice. Not that I'm holding my breath.
Your callousness about people I know who died in the WTC has not been
forgotten by members of this list.
This was distributed via the memetics list associated with the
Journal of Memetics - Evolutionary Models of Information Transmission
For information about the journal and the list (e.g. unsubscribing)
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Sun 15 Dec 2002 - 04:29:02 GMT